Loafers vs Dress Shoes: What are the Differences & Which is Right for You?

When it comes to formal footwear, you have quite a few choices. But two stand out as the most popular options - loafers and traditional dress shoes. Which of these is right for you, though? After all, you want to put your best foot forward when piecing your outfit together - your shoes play a huge role in this. Don't worry - Del Toro is here to help!

The loafers vs. dress shoes debate is a tale as old as time. Both shoe types are unique, but one is the premier choice in style, comfort, and versatility. Below on this page, we'll explain why we believe loafers are the superior shoe. First, let's unpack loafers and dress shoes separately before comparing and contrasting them.

Check out Del Toro's collection of Italian handmade loafers for men and women. Each product page includes a size guide to improve your buying experience.

What are Loafers?

Loafers are slip-on shoes, usually made of leather or suede. Our velvet loafers offer a captivating alternative for those seeking a touch of audacious refinement while retaining the quintessential sophistication that defines this iconic footwear.

Loafers come in varying styles and can be embellished with tassels, buckles, fringes, and other decorations for added detail. They are an iconic shoe style that has been around for centuries and were worn by European horsemen in the 1600s. However, as we know them today, loafers have only existed since the 1930s, when they became popular among wealthy individuals who wanted stylish yet comfortable shoes to wear to sporting events.

Loafers have a rich history, dating back to the 1600s when European horsemen sported these slip-on wonders. One can only imagine the envious glances they received as they effortlessly mounted their steeds, their loafers whispering tales of comfort and style.

Loafers are known for their casual yet dressy look - allowing you to dress up any outfit without being too formal or laidback. Loafers are one of the most versatile footwear men and women can have in their wardrobes. You can wear everyday loafers with coats and jackets or formal loafers with work outfits. You can even wear yacht loafers with jeans or shorts if kept neat.

Regarding loafers, comfort is essential—and Del Toro's loafers offer just that. This is thanks to our handcrafted construction and luxurious materials, like premium calfskin leather, crafted in Italy by experienced artisans who use traditional methods that have been perfected over the years. More on that later. First, let's introduce the other half of the loafers vs. dress shoes debate.

What are Dress Shoes?

Dress shoes (also known as Oxfords) are slightly more formal than loafers. They typically have closed lacing whereby the eyelets are sewn directly onto the vamp. They feature either a plain toe cap or one adorned with stitches along its edge, creating subtle texture and patterns. Unlike loafers, dress shoes require laces, instantly giving them a more classic look. However, some feel that the laces of dress shoes detract from the materials and overall silhouette of the shoe.

Dress shoes come in a variety of styles, including brogues, derbys or bluchers (which feature open lacing), wingtips, monks straps (with buckles instead of laces), kilties (which feature decorative fringes along the tongue), loafers (combining elements from both loafers and traditional dress shoes), and many more! Dress shoes are usually made of leather but can also be found in suede or fabric, depending on your desired style and needs.

Dress shoes undoubtedly exude sophistication, making them perfect for formal occasions such as weddings, black-tie events, board meetings, etc. They are timeless due to their classic design elements, such as medallion toe caps or cap toes.

It's worth noting, however, that while dress shoes provide a certain level of elegance not found in a pair of loafers, they can be uncomfortable if not chosen carefully! Comfort is one of the key considerations to remember when searching for the perfect Italian shoe. So, without any further ado, let's unpack the loafers vs. dress shoes debate.

Loafers vs Dress Shoes: Which is Right For You?

Now that we've covered both types of footwear separately, let's compare them directly. Both loafers and dress shoes have a time and place, so you must decide which style best suits your needs before investing in one pair of shoes over the other. Let's start by assessing the style aspect—something most people put at the top of their criteria when choosing a shoe.

Which is More Stylish?

When it comes to style, both will help enhance your overall look, depending on what you're wearing. Loafers add an air of authority and classiness, whereas dress shoes relax elegance and professionalism.

If you want to turn heads, loafers are the ideal pick. They are more sophisticated and eye-catching. You'll stand out in a crowded room with stunning loafers on your feet, whereas those wearing dress shoes tend to blend in with the rest of the crowd.

Ultimately, it's up to personal preference which one looks better, so go with whichever catches your eye.

Which is More Comfortable?

In terms of comfort, loafers win hands down every time! Thanks to their soft leather uppers, loafers don't require a break-in period and offer excellent breathability, meaning they can be worn right out of the box without any issues!

On the other hand, while many modern-day dress shoe designs offer cushioning at specific pressure points, most still need some breaking in before feeling genuinely comfortable. Hence, loafers are much better suited for long walks around town or standing on your feet.

To enjoy the comfort offered by Italian loafers, you need to choose the best loafers and we'll point you in the right direction for that later. First, let's talk about versatility.

Which is More Versatile?

When you're looking to buy new shoes, you must ensure they will get worn. Ultimately, this goes back to personal preference. With how fluid the definitions of "casual" or "formal" are, there can be no single answer.

That said, we believe loafers are among the most versatile types of footwear that men and women can add to their wardrobes. We spoke on this a bit earlier. While some view loafers as business casual, others view them as formal footwear. Meanwhile, some will wear their loafers with shorts and a T-shirt. No other shoe can be dressed up or down like the loafer.

On the other hand, most dress shoe styles tend to look out of place when paired outside particular scenarios like boardroom meetings. You're limited to semi-formal or formal wear with dress shoes.

The Verdict: Stick With Loafers!

As you can see, loafers are the superior choice in terms of style, comfort, and versatility. You won't be limited to any one particular dress code or look - loafers have the potential to take you anywhere! And - you'll look good no matter what setting you're stepping into.

But why settle for anything less than the best for your loafers? At Del Toro Shoes, we have a wide range of Italian loafers made from the finest materials and crafted with time-honored traditions of Italian shoemaking. With our loafers, you get luxurious comfort along with unmatched style.

So, if you're looking for loafers that won't break the bank, head to Del Toro today and treat yourself! Our selection is sure to exceed your expectations. We've got both Italian loafers for men and Italian loafers for women - see what the hype is all about by exploring our catalog yourself today.

Featured Loafers

Some of our featured products showcase how loafers look great for various occasions.

The Centesimo Penny Loafers

Meet the Centesimo Penny Loafer – our take on the timeless penny loafer design. The team at Del Toro spent years designing and perfecting this shoe, making it the most comfortable loafer in the lineup.

The Centesimo is inspired by refined Italian menswear and is handcrafted by our skilled family of artisans across Italy. The uppers are made from the softest Italian leathers and suedes, offering a comfortable, broken-in feel right from the start. A custom sole enhances its sophistication, featuring a carefully designed rubber injection to prevent slipping.

The Centesimo works whether you wear it to the office, a night out, or a quick trip to the bodega. It is the perfect wardrobe staple.

The Milano Tassel Loafers

Meet the Milano Loafer – our best-selling silhouette that gives a modern perspective to a classically cool design. Inspired by the refined looks found in one of the world’s most well-dressed cities, the Milano Black Tassel Loafer is handcrafted by our family of artisans throughout Italy.

The uppers are constructed from soft, high-grade Italian Velvet and complemented with the hand-stitched quality detailing that Del Toro has become known for. A custom rubber sole adds an element of sophistication and sturdiness, giving the shoe a durable, handmade feel that can only be found in Italy.

Designed for a broken-in feel right out of the box, the Milano Black Tassel Loafer is versatile, comfortable, and stylish. Pair it with any outfit—a suit, jeans, or even joggers—and the Milano is your go-to everyday loafer.

Suede Loafers

Suede loafers are a popular choice for casual and semi-formal occasions. These shoes offer a unique blend of comfort, style, and sophistication that can elevate any outfit. Let's explore their characteristics to understand better how suede loafers fit into this broad footwear category.

Suede loafers are distinguished by their soft texture and luxurious appearance, making them an appealing option for fashionable footwear. Crafted from the underside of animal hides, suede offers a unique finish that exudes elegance and charm. This material is visually striking and provides a degree of breathability while offering ease of wear for various climates.

Leather Loafers

Leather Loafers crafted by Del Toro are a timeless staple in Italian footwear. They combine classic design with practical functionality. Made from high-quality leather, these loafers showcase a polished finish that lends a sophisticated touch to any ensemble.

Leather loafers boast a sleek design and minimal ornamentation, making them versatile for formal and casual occasions. Their durable material develops a rich patina over time, enhancing their appeal. They typically feature cushioned insoles that mold to your foot, ensuring comfort for all-day wear at work or social events.

Boat Shoes

Boat shoes represent a unique fusion of style and practicality, making them a staple for casual outings and nautical adventures. Originating from the need for slip-resistant footwear on boats, they have become a fashionable option for those who appreciate a laid-back yet polished look.

Boat shoes are known for their moccasin construction, featuring a leather upper and rubber soles for excellent grip. Their exposed lacing system ensures a secure fit and adds elegance, with 360-degree lacing for customization.

They have a casual yet refined look and come in rich earth tones suitable for various outfits, from shorts to tailored suits. Their design allows for easy transitions from boats to cafés while maintaining style.